Last October I wrote a post about bread. This week I find myself at the centre of an expanding dough debate. It seems that I have become some sort of agony aunt for amateur bakers, when truth be told, that’s all I amount to myself.
Fall 2011 Guest Service Intern Sarah Russell is back in Michigan and has propagated her own starter using the ‘breadbasket’s’ finest resources. My sister Anne, on the west coast of Ireland, received (as her Christmas gift from me) a jar of offspring from my pasta madre. So Sarah and Anne are now mothers to their own, erm, mothers (?) and have been updating me regularly on their progress. Sarah’s most recent email to me was an absolute hoot. Paragraph after intense paragraph of inquiry and description. Actually, here, read it for yourself:
Woo hoo! I am about to go bread-wild on you, so get ready. I am just elated to have someone to discuss this with because I have been ruminating with thoughts of bread for the past three weeks and wasn’t sure if you would indulge me.
So, I did get the Tartine book, which is amazing. I am so eager to try so many of the recipes in it, but I want to get the Basic Country Sourdough down first. I got a natural starter going just a few days after I got home from Italy, so it has been alive and kickin’ for almost a month now. I feed it every morning with the 50/50 blend (half white, half whole-wheat) which seems to be working well. The whole bread making process just takes so freakin’ long, so I am curious to hear how you do it? I remember you babying it throughout the day, but I can’t imagine that you devoted as much time to checking it, turning it, smelling it, and just plain waiting for it as I did, or else you really are a saint for making it for and sharing it with us! I made the mistake of starting my leaven in the morning the first time. It was ready (passed the float test!) by evening, then I stayed up well into the night, waking up every half hour to turn it, during the bulk fermentation. This first batch didn’t work. I think that the house was too cool (68 degrees F); I didn’t give it long enough; and my starter may have been too immature. It didn’t rise in the oven at all either. It was dense, gummy, and lacked flavor.
So, this last time, I did as Tartine suggests: I made my leaven the evening before, so it was ready for me to mix the dough in the morning. My bulk fermentation took longer than the 3 to 4 hours that they suggest. After 6 hours, I decided I couldn’t wait any longer, so I went ahead and pre-shaped the loaves. After the final shaping, I let the first loaf rise for only 2 hours before baking because I was eager to have one ready to eat with mussels for dinner that night. I was literally floored when I took the lid off halfway through baking to see that it had really sprung in the oven! Glory! Hallelujah! It looked great, there were some decent sized holes and the crust was fantastic. The flavor lacked the sour taste that I long for, and the after taste was a bit too much like soggy cereal. While we ate dinner, I left the second loaf to continue rising and didn’t get around to baking it off until 5 hours after the final shaping (3 hours longer than the first). There weren’t as many large holes as the first loaf, but the flavor was more sour. I preferred this loaf to the first. I don’t know what made the flavor different though. It could have been a number of things: the longer rise after the final shaping, the scoring on top, a slightly longer baking time? Who knows. I am curious to hear your thoughts though, and I want to hear ALL about your processes, and what you have learned, or are still puzzled by.
[…] What do you think about feeding the starter twice a day? I only do it in the morning now, but by around 5 pm, it is at its most active. Then, by the following morning, it has died down a bit and has begun to dry out on top. The guys from Tartine said that they feed theirs several times a day, which is bogus, but I am considering doing it. What do you think?!
Do you leave your starter out, or put it in the refrigerator? I really want to put mine in the fridge because, that way, I wouldn’t have to feed it as often, and I would like to see how the lactic acid production changes the flavor (I prefer a more sour taste). […]
There was more, but this is a blog, not a multi-volume encyclopedia on the properties of gluten. In reading Sarah’s email, I can recall Gracie’s face with supreme accuracy as I fired my own questions at her last summer; Where are my bubbles? Why is my dough too loose? Can I turn this now? What have I done wrong? What her voice didn’t communicate then - but her furrowed brow did - was this; Look girlie, if you can keep up with this bread making business, you’ll figure it out for yourself. We all make our own loaves in this crazy world.
The truth is that you can read as many chapters of Harold McGee as you like, you can investigate the photos in the Tartine bread book with a monocle, heck, you can even work an internship there (if you are lucky), but nothing, nothing can educate you in the ways of bread better than your own senses. If you want to break it, you have to make it, and make it, and make it, and make it, and make it…
A presto…